Did a children’s film about Midas’ golden touch slip a hidden protest past the Iron Curtain?

Midas

In a chapter from a new book, Animation and the Ancient World, Dr Frances Foster suggests that a charming 1960s children's film about King Midas may have concealed a protest about life in the Eastern Bloc.

In 1963, the Polish animation studio Se-Ma-For released a short stop-motion film that appeared, to the casual observer, simply to be retelling a famous ancient tale.

Król Midas
– or “King Midas” – is a 10-minute silent animation about the king who, according to legend, acquired the ability to turn anything he touched into gold. Outwardly, the film, by Lucjan Dembiński (best known for his later work on The Moomins) seems little more than a charming children’s rendition of this ancient myth.

Maybe, though, there was more to it than meets the eye. According to a new study by a Cambridge academic, any adults watching in 1960s Communist Europe may, as the action unfolded, have noticed a subtle critique about the authoritarian states behind the Iron Curtain.

The argument is advanced in a chapter written by Dr Frances Foster, from Cambridge’s Faculty of Education, for the new book Animation and the Ancient World. Foster raises the possibility that Król Midas was sneaking a hidden protest past the Polish regime’s censors at a time when speaking out against the government could mean imprisonment, or worse.

"A ruler becoming a danger to everyone around him through his all-consuming lust for power had a very particular political resonance."

Her argument hinges on the fact that Dembiński blended and altered existing versions of the Midas story. In other versions, Midas is often a comical, naïve figure who requests his “golden touch” and later regrets his decision. In Dembiński’s 1960s reboot, however, the touch is a curse resulting from his lust for wealth and power.

The pivotal moment occurs when Midas steals his own daughter’s crown – a symbol of her authority – and stashes it in his treasure vault. This causes him to acquire his magical, but devastating, ability.

“To audiences in 1960s Poland, living under a communist regime, the idea of a ruler becoming a danger to everyone around him through his all-consuming lust for power had a very particular political resonance,” Foster said. “If political commentary was Dembiński’s aim, he disguised it in a surprisingly detailed reconstruction of the ancient world.”

Excavations comparable to those of Tutankhamun's tomb

Foster, who studies how stories and ideas from the ancient past have been – and continue to be – read, used and understood, was drawn to Król Midas by that extraordinary attention to classical detail.

Six years earlier, in 1957, archaeologists had excavated the “Midas mound” on the site of the ancient city of Gordion in Anatolia, Turkey. This was thought to be the burial site of the real Midas, who ruled Phrygia in the 8th century BCE.

Historians now believe it belonged to Midas’ father, but at the time the excavation was huge international news – on a par, in the eyes of one commentator, with that of the tomb of Tutankhamun. “It is pretty clear that when making this film, Dembiński had done his homework and was influenced by what they had found,” Foster said.

The archaeologists, to the disappointment of those invested in Midas’ mythical reputation, unearthed little gold. They did, however, find plentiful evidence that Phrygia was a major trading power, with connections to places like Egypt and Crete.

Midas mound

The "Tomb of Midas" in Gordion

The "Tomb of Midas" in Gordion

Unusually for a children’s film, this material evidence was incorporated into Król Midas. Foster shows that its design took inspiration from real-life Assyrian reliefs, Cretan statuettes and depictions of Mycenaean soldiers. It even features tiny models of pottery from Gordion.

More niche still was its use of what we would now recognise as ‘Easter eggs’ for ancient history buffs. In Midas’ palace, for example, the reflective floors resemble water and the curtains hanging above them bear the Egyptian hieroglyph, mw, meaning “water ripple”. The door to Midas’ treasure vault contains a carving of the Medusa, who famously turned her victims into stone – a nod to Midas’ own petrifying powers.

"We tend to forget that children’s media are always aimed partly at the adults watching."

A hidden subtext?

These references are too plentiful to be coincidences – so what were they doing in a children’s film? Foster thinks that Dembiński may have been inviting audiences in the know to look for a hidden subtext.

The variety of authentic features, she suggests, reflects the emerging historical understanding that Phrygia’s power was built on cultural wealth and interconnectedness with the wider world. Having created a visual shorthand for that reality, Król Midas shows Midas destroying it as his golden touch fossilises the kingdom: turning flowers, insects and even his daughter into metal. Frame rates and pauses in the animation deliberately enhance this effect.

Dembiński then put his own twist on the myth. In a silent animation, Midas could not ask for his golden touch, so instead he is cursed with the ability after stealing his daughter’s crown – and it is likewise the return of the crown that restores her to life.

Nathaniel Hawthorne's version of the Midas myth, from the 19th century, introduced the character of the daughter.

Nathaniel Hawthorne's version of the Midas myth, from the 19th century, introduced the character of the daughter.

Nathaniel Hawthorne's version of the Midas myth, from the 19th century, introduced the character of the daughter.

All this, Foster suggests, would have been highly symbolic in the “Polish People’s Republic” of the 1960s, and any other Eastern Bloc countries where it was shown. Poland’s government maintained its control through severe political repression, the secret police and tight censorship. Some cultural concessions were made, however, and the regime supported entertainment for younger viewers.

For those willing to risk it, a children’s production like Król Midas was therefore an ideal vehicle for hidden political dissent. Perhaps, Foster suggests, Dembiński was expressing exactly that, with his depiction of an authoritarian ruler whose lust for wealth and control sucks the life, variety and colour out of his people.

Like the censors, this was doubtless lost on the children watching – but perhaps not their parents. “In a country with a long history of being consumed by its neighbours’ imperial ambitions, it doesn’t seem too much of a leap to suggest Król Midas had an allegorical dimension,” Foster said. “We tend to forget that children’s media are always aimed partly at the adults watching.”

Animation and the Ancient World is published by
Oxford University Press. University of Cambridge staff and students can find the book on iDiscover.

Images in this story (Top to bottom):

King Midas on a red-figure stamnos from Chiusi around 440 BC, British Museum. By The Midas Painter - File:Red-figure_stamnos_Silenos_Mida_440BC.jpg, CC BY-SA 4.0.

The "Tomb of Midas" in Gordion, dated 740 BCE. By Dennis G. Jarvis - Turkey-1428, CC BY-SA 2.0.

In the
Nathaniel Hawthorne version of the Midas myth, Midas's daughter turns to a golden statue when he touches her (illustration by Walter Crane for the 1893 edition). By Walter Crane - Library of Congress[2], Public Domain.